Thursday, March 20, 2014

External Assessment: Musical Links Investigation


Musical Links Investigation


“Empty Air” and “The Clock”: Six Hundred Years, Eight Time Zones, Yet Only a Few Musical Links Apart


Linking
La Campanella, an etude by Franz Liszt
Koku, a traditional Japanese shakuhachi piece


By Tina Yu-Ting Wu
Candidate number 004914-0043
IB Music SL
May 2014 session
Word count: 1996




Introduction

虛空, referred to as Koku, or “Empty Air”, is a traditional Japanese shakuhachi piece composed in the 13th century by, legend says, a monk named Kyuchiku (Nelson, 2014). It consists of a slow melodic line that was not meant to be elaborate or grandiose, instead, one that represents the topic in question, “Empty Air”, in an empty and airy way (even featuring a breath attack) and evokes a feeling that sets the mood for meditation.
La Campanella, or “The Clock”, is a western art music piece by a renowned early Romantic composer, Franz Liszt. It is based on a steady rhythm, where the left or right hand always has a consistent rhythm that’s on beat and not syncopated, creating a clock-like steady ticking, though with a faster tempo.
Even though these two pieces seem to be completely different, there are many musical links to observe that bridge them together. Due to the big difference between what these two pieces sound like, the similarities between them seem artificially small, but when they are discussed, the links are strong. This investigation will be based on two major links and some similarities and differences on the side, as we discover that these two pieces can share links and have differences within musical elements upon more detailed observations.
To get us started, the table below and the fundamental similarities section afterwards outline some basic musical characteristics of both pieces and whether they are more on the similar or different side within each musical element. After that, we will focus on investigating two main links today, where the first link is how both their main melodies are constructed to show clear tonality, yet not strictly containing only the notes in the key, and the second link is how they both have an expressive nature evident through contrasting dynamics and flexibility in tempo.





<Basic Comparison Between Koku and La Campanella>
The table below shows a list of some important musical elements, the basic properties of each piece within those elements, and a short note of comparison.
♫?
Musical element
Koku
La Campanella
Compare/contrast point
♫
Meter
2/4, simple duple
6/8, compound duple
Both duple time

Tempo
60 bpm
allegretto, 100 bpm (
Big difference in speed

Rhythm
Unstable rhythm
Defined rhythm
Difference in rhythm

Tonality
E pentatonic (Japanese in-scale)
G sharp minor
One is pentatonic and one is diatonic
♫
Instrumentation
Only shakuhachi
Only piano
One instrument only
♫
Dynamics
From p to ff, many crescendos and diminuendos
From p to ff, many crescendos and diminuendos
Same dynamic range (from piano to fortissimo) and both include big contrasts
♫
Texture
Monophonic
Monophonic
Both monophonic

Structure
Loose structure, jumps right in
Variations on a theme with intro
Many major differences in structure

♫ represents that the musical element in question is more of a link rather than difference between Koku and La Campanella



Motif and Repetition of Melody
To better understand the pieces discussed today, we must talk about the motifs and main phrases. These two pieces, similarly, both have their own dominant motif presented in slightly different ways throughout the piece. However, they differ in that Koku uses a more flexible structure to present its simple melody, while La Campanella utilizes the structure of variations on a theme to present its more complex melodic line.

Repetition of motifs in Koku:

Excerpt 1-1: bars 1~3 and bars 32~34
These two different parts of Koku have the same long note.


Excerpt 1-2: bars 19~22
These bars produce a melody that sounds familiar, but features the notes A and B instead of D and E, a shift of a perfect fifth interval upwards, then an octave downwards.




Repetition of motifs in La Campanella:

Theme A - bars 5~21
Excerpt 2-1: bars 5~92 (right hand, treble clef)
Appearance of the motif, melody of Theme A.


Theme A1, a variation on A - bars 43~69
Excerpt 2-2: bars 43-48 (left hand, treble clef → bass clef in bar 46)
The left hand plays main melody and follows same rhythm and harmony as in theme A, but without the extra note an octave lower after every note of the main melody.


Theme A2 - bars 81~97
Excerpt 2-3: bars 81-85 (left hand, treble clef)
The left hand plays main melody again, same as in theme A1, only some small extra notes added in, but the main melody is evident in lower, slower, clearer notes. This time there’s a slur in bar 831 instead of staccato like previous appearances of those notes (bars 451 and 71).




Tonal Yet Not Completely: Exploring Melodic Elements
They both have a monophonic texture, which means they both have one obvious main melody throughout. This is evident in both pieces, where Koku has only one part overall and La Campanella has one obvious melodic line despite the variety of harmony implemented.
As a Romantic and not contemporary piece, La Campanella includes a pretty dominant and clear tonality, but as a Romantic and not Classical or Baroque piece, it also isn’t as strict with tonality. The Koku has a similar property, as it belongs to a scale, yet somehow doesn’t completely belong. How is this achieved in both pieces? Liszt and Kyuchiku seem to have used a similar technique. They both included only notes within the respective scales in the main melody, but that only applies to the main melody as Koku only uses E, F, A, B, and D as full length notes and La Campanella’s main melody is all part of the G sharp harmonic minor key. Example: Theme A is #D-#D-#C-B-B-#A-#G-G-#G-#A-#D-#D-E-#D-#C. However, apart from the main melody, they both use notes outside the scale for parts of less significance. La Campanella features notes outside of the key for elaborate effects and tension-creating harmony. Liszt incorporated many chromatic scales within the piece, such as in bars 38~41 (excerpt 3-1 below) and bar 75 (excerpt 3-2 below)

Chromatic scales in  La Campanella
Excerpt 3-1: bars 38~41 (both hands treble clef, right hand an octave higher ottava alta)
The left hand from bars 38~402 and the bottom note of the right hand part from bar 402~41 show an ascending chromatic scale, from D (or C double sharp) to #D one octave and a semitone higher.


Excerpt 3-2: bar 75 (right hand, treble clef with ottava alta)
Ascending then descending chromatic (mostly) scale with an overall range of D to #F a compound major third interval away.
To further create the effect of using notes not within the key, Liszt also sneaks in accidentals as harmony or part of the variation on the melody outside of the current key. This is evident as early as bar 8 (excerpt 4-1 below) and throughout the piece, appearing in various instances and in both theme A and theme B, such as in bar 31.

Use of harmony with notes not in the scale in La Campanella

(photo credit: basicmusictheory.com, details in bibliography below)

Excerpt 4-1: bar 8 (both hands treble clef)


In theme A, the motif is presented in the tonic of #G minor as the melodic line features only notes from the key. However, the chord serving as the harmony in the left hand contains the notes B-D-F, which contains the mediant of #G harmonic minor, B, along with two notes, D and F, that don’t belong to the key.





Excerpt 4-2: bar 76 (both hands treble clef)


In this excerpt, the tonality is at #G harmonic minor, however, the left hand is consisted of the chord #D-G-#D, which includes only notes within the key, and the chord F-#G-D, where F and D are not within the key.
Achieving the same effect, Koku sneaks in the G note in its pentatonic E Japanese in-scale of the notes E-F-A-B-D through small notes but not notes with regular length, such as in the form of acciaccatura in bars 14~16, , and breath attack in bar 24 .
Speaking of the “breath attack”, the Koku possesses its own special shakuhachi techniques not present in Liszt’s area, keyboard pieces, or culture, Western music. The breath attack is one of them, where a note is played with more force, causing the note to sound breathy and less melodic. With the piano as the only instrument in La Campanella, there are no such techniques that take away the melodic feeling of the instrument (until John Cage explored the idea of a prepared piano, that is). In terms of how melodic the pieces are, these two pieces differ greatly as Koku is more about the idea of “Empty Air” than the melodic properties itself, while La Campanella is focused on the main melodic line and merely incorporates dominant elements of, such as stable rhythm, rather than emphasizing that it’s about “The Clock”.
In summary, both Koku and La Campanella have a clear tonality, yet use notes outside their respective scales of E pentatonic in-scale and #G harmonic minor sometimes, just not in the main melody, creating more of a variety and tension to provide a contrast to its strong tonality. However, they differ in that La Campanella focuses on what the melodic line sounds like musically, but also keeping in mind the imagery by incorporating elements resembling its title meaning “The Clock”, while Koku focuses on the imagery by creating a breathy and floaty “Empty Air” atmosphere to match its title, as the melodic line’s musicality or how interesting or elaborate its main melody is seems to come after the priority of imagery.





Expressive Presentations: Dynamics and Flexibility in Tempo
Both Koku and La Campanella are expressive in nature, evident through their great flexibility and contrast in both dynamics and pacing. They both have directions that suggest flexible tempo. In Koku, the tempo is indicated on a score with directions that explicitly state this, while La Campanella has expression marks that indicate it throughout.

Evidence of Flexible Tempo
Koku:
Excerpt 5-1: Tempo marking

“but quite flexible” is directly used to indicate flexible pacing.




La Campanella Expression marks:
Excerpt 5-2: bar 50, “poco rit.”, and bar 90, “smorz.”



“Rit.” is short for “ritardando”, which means to go slower, and “smorz.” is short for “smorzando”, this expression mark means that this part is to be played with gradual diminuendo and gradual ritardando.



In terms of dynamics, Koku uses a lot of dynamics change by including crescendo or diminuendo, as well as contrasting dynamic instructions. Almost every bar contains a dynamic instruction, hinting at rapid dynamic change, which makes Koku an expressive piece dynamically.
Dynamic contrast in Koku:
Excerpt 6-1: Diminuendo only, bars 3~4 and bars 8~9

These instances show use of diminuendo during long notes, creating less strictness and more expression in notes that are long but still not completely “stable”.



Excerpt 6-2: More complex dynamic progression, bars 13~16 and bars 20~22

These instances show diminuendo and crescendo being put together within a phrase. There are rapid, yet not sudden, changes in dynamics present.


Excerpt 6-3: Use of dynamic markings with great contrast, bars 6, 18~19, and 24~30

These instances go from forte to piano, piano to forte, and forte to pianissimo. These provide great contrast.

The whole piece contains many long notes that allow for what is most likely the emphasis of Koku, allowing the shakuhachi master to delve into the rhythmic and dynamic expression to create the visual and auditory imagery and atmosphere that portray “empty air”.

Similarly, La Campanella contains many dynamic markings and instructions that allow for expression using dynamics.

Contrasting dynamics in La Campanella:
Excerpt 7-1: Accentuating the theme, bars 5~6

“Ma sempre bon marcato il tema” means “il tema”, or the theme, “sempre”, or always, “marcato”, should be marked or accentuated. This is an indication of a dynamic marking to make the main melodic line louder than the harmony and other elements of the piece.


Excerpt 7-2: Dynamic changes in short periods of time, bars 38~39

Both the right hand and left hand feature sudden dynamic changes in short periods of time, with three dynamic markings within each bar.





Excerpt 7-3: Explicit statement to be expressive, bar 941

In bar 94, we can see the marking “espressivo”, which explicitly tells us that this part should be played in an expressive way.

Overall, both pieces contain many instructions for dynamic and tempo flexibility, though La Campanella features more written instructions that Koku does not possess, and Koku features many more rapid yet never as sudden as in excerpt 7-1 or 7-2, where accents are used.



In a nutshell, there are many musical similarities and differences between Koku and La Campanella. The differences are obvious at first glance, while the similarities not so much. However, these two pieces, though six hundred years and halfway around the world from each other, contain strong, major, musical links based on melodic construction and their expressive nature, and those links, though require some effort to spot, become obvious as we find that the two pieces can be strongly linked after observation and investigation.





Discography:

  • Traditional Japanese piece for Shakuhachi. Koku. Perf. Cond. Giuseppe Sinopoli. Warner, 1996.
  • Liszt, Franz. La Campanella. Perf. Yundi Li. “La Campanella by Yundi Li”. Youtube. Retrieved from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hEnfZjqMSy0 on May 3, 2013.


Scores used:



Bibliography:

No comments:

Post a Comment